It’s interesting how stories about child protection and youth justice from different parts of the world often mirror what’s happening here in Ireland.
A story from the U.S. this week reports on the dearth of data and information about youth in the juvenile justice system.
The report is called Denied Existence and calls on the authorities to implement a comprehensive juvenile-justice data collection system.
This certainly reflects the Irish situation, where we know very little about these youth.
The Courts Services collates scant detail about young people in court, and monitoring of oversight of outcomes for the 3,000 plus young people moving through the youth courts is almost nonexistent.
A recent audit of the Irish youth justice states: Currently, a centralised source of information regarding young offenders and young offending in Ireland does not exist. As outlined by the Convention on the Rights of the Child, this information is essential to establish effective systems for data collection and to ensure that the data collected is evaluated and used to assess progress in implementation, to identify problems and to inform all policy development for children.
It points out that as far back as 1985, a government report stated a “continuing need for research analysis, discussion and deeper understanding of the issue of juvenile offenders in Ireland.”
As with the U.S. study, the Irish paper highlights the “need for an independent agency responsible for maintaining a centralised, contemporaneous resource of data pertaining to young offenders and youth offending in Ireland.”
How long more will we be waiting?